I have developed a deep appreciation for the efforts undertaken by the interim government and the first elected government to build India. Nation-building is a formidable task, and the foundations laid by the initial governments have paved the way for the world's largest democracy we see today. The book I am reviewing, titled "1947-1957 India - The Birth of a Republic" delves into the political turmoil, governmental actions, schemes, and everything political that transpired in India during this crucial period. Follow the pointers,
Initial Impressions of the Book
Upon first encountering the book in the market, I was immediately drawn to it. The title, "1947-1957, India: The Birth of a Republic" suggests a comprehensive exploration of the political landscape, government actions, and schemes during this time. While not an art student, my passion for history since childhood helped me grasp most of the content. However, it's evident that understanding the events and assembling the chronological incidents requires a well-trained and deep mind.
Why is Chandrachur Ghose the most fitting choice to write that Book?
Chandrachur Ghose is aptly chosen for this monumental task, akin to a superhero. His efforts to persuade the government to release documents related to Subash Chandra Bose's mystery showcase his dedication to uncovering historical truths. Having watched the movie "Gumnami" based on Bose's mystery, I witnessed Ghose's sacrifices and efforts to reveal the truth. His commitment to researching freedom fighters and giving them the honor they deserve aligns him with a true patriot. The book, "1947-1957 India - The Birth of a Republic," is a result of Ghose's extensive research, hard work, and knowledge gained from his previous works.
Analysis of 1947-1957, India: The Birth of a Republic
The 300-page book condenses its content into 260 pages across eight chapters. Despite being an avid reader of lengthy books like "Breavehearts" by Vikram Sampat, this book took me two weeks to complete due to its complexity. Each chapter sheds light on the machinery at work during the crucial 10 years, covering incidents before 1947, the establishment of the interim government in 1946, and discussions during the formation of the constitution. The book meticulously details the transformation of various government bodies, including the police, ICS (IAS), intelligence agencies, Indian states, foreign relations, and more.
Three Lessons from the Book
Mountbatten's Choice - Patel
Chapter 3, page no, 61- when the proposal of the states department was approved by the interim cabinet on 25 june 1947. which is responsible for the merjer of states into the dominion of India. Sardar Patel got the charge of this department.
Mountbatten recorded his views in his report of 27 June "I am glad to say that Nehru has not been put in charge of the new states department, which would have wrecked everything. Patel, who is essentially a realist and very sensible, is going to take over."
Hari Vishnu Kamath: The Legend
As most of you already know, Subash Chandra Bose was the first man to reject his ICS post after clearing the exam because he didn't want to suppress his own people with this British post.
At that time, most of the youngsters were inspired by Bose, but no one dared to give up his ICS post for the nation. However, Hari Vishnu Kamath (Chapter 5, Page no 100) was the only other Indian to resign from the ICS and join the national movement, which he did in 1938."
Ambedkar's Objection to Nehru's Muslim Appeasement Politics
Chapter 6, page 162: Ambedkar posed a question.
The Prime Minister's entire time and attention are devoted to the protection of Muslims. I yield to none, not even to the Prime Minister, in my desire to provide the utmost protection to the Muslims of India whenever they stand in need of it. But what I want to know is, are Muslims the only people who need protection?
The audience I would recommend this book to
This book, offering a comprehensive analysis of India's political progress and turbulence from 1947 to 1957, best suits individuals with a clear understanding of basic history. It is precious for students preparing for UPSC or other government exams, providing an in-depth insight into this crucial period. However, for those without a foundational knowledge of history, the book may prove challenging to grasp.
Comments